| Published June 25, 2025
Born in Uganda to a family of Indian descent, Mamdani, who would be the city’s first Muslim mayor, has a history of pro-Palestinian activism.
New York City, June 25, 2025 — A flurry of alarming calls from Jewish advocacy groups erupted on June 25 after self-described Democratic Socialist Zohran Mamdani secured the Democratic nomination for mayor of New York City. Noted for his vocal pro-Palestinian stance, critics accuse him of sowing unrest and posing risks to Jewish residents.
🚨 “Evacuate NYC immediately”
The Republican Jewish Coalition (RJC) took to X (formerly Twitter), branding Mamdani a “raging antisemite, anti‑America, anti‑Israel Democrat Socialist” and warning:
“Evacuate NYC immediately. Thank you for your attention to this matter.”
RJC accused prominent Democrats—including Senator Schumer, Rep. Jeffries, and Governor Hochul—of failing Jewish Americans by not opposing Mamdani, stating this primary result highlights “radical extremists” within the party.
✡️ Betar USA Gives Stern Warning
The Zionist youth movement Betar USA echoed the alarm, urging all Jewish residents to leave the city. A stark X post read:
“We urge all Jews to evacuate NYC.”
Their messaging featured charged imagery, with hashtags like “Rip nyc!” and references to a “globalized intifada”, underscoring deep-seated fears.
🔎 Context: Mamdani’s Candidacy
-
Zohran Mamdani, of Ugandan-Indian heritage, would become NYC’s first Muslim mayor if elected. He beat Andrew Cuomo and other establishment figures by appealing to progressive voters.
-
Known for pro‑Palestinian activism and critical views on Israeli policy, Mamdani’s win has illuminated concerns within the Jewish community.
📰 Why These Groups Are Alarmed
-
Foreign policy rhetoric: Mamdani’s critiques of Israel have alarmed pro‑Israel advocates, who fear his platform signals a shift in NYC’s stance on Jewish interests.
-
Perceived threats: Phrases like “raging antisemite” and “intifada” show an intense level of anxiety—regardless of whether actual policies would endanger Jewish New Yorkers.
-
Political signaling: Evacuation calls—echoed by both RJC and Betar—symbolize a broader sentiment: Jewish organizations feel politically abandoned by Democratic leadership.
Support and Opposition
🟩 Support for the Evacuation Warning
-
Republican Jewish Coalition (RJC): Strongly supports the evacuation call, citing Mamdani’s history of anti-Israel rhetoric. They describe his nomination as “a betrayal of Jewish voters by Democratic leaders.”
-
Betar USA: Endorsed the evacuation appeal, stating that Jewish safety in NYC is compromised under a potential Mamdani administration.
-
Pro-Israel groups and commentators: Emphasize a growing atmosphere of hostility and fear, pointing to global pro-Palestinian movements that they say have emboldened antisemitic actions.
🟥 Opposition to the Evacuation Warning
-
Progressive Jewish Groups (e.g., Jewish Voice for Peace): Condemn the evacuation calls as fear-mongering and politically motivated. They argue Mamdani’s positions are critical of Israeli government policy, not antisemitic.
-
Local NYC officials: Urge calm, emphasizing that NYC remains a safe city for Jewish residents. No credible threats or policy proposals from Mamdani justify mass departure.
-
Civil rights groups: Warn that such evacuation rhetoric could incite division and paranoia, particularly against Muslims or Arab Americans.
Bottom Line:
Zohran Mamdani’s victory in the Democratic primary has ignited deep divisions in New York City’s political and cultural landscape. While some Jewish organizations interpret his rise as a direct threat to their community’s safety and values—prompting rare calls for evacuation—others see these warnings as extreme and politically charged. The controversy highlights not only the widening rift over U.S. policy on Israel and Palestine but also the broader challenges of religious coexistence and political trust in one of America’s most diverse cities. As the general election approaches, the tensions sparked by this moment will likely shape the future tone of civic discourse—and the decisions of many New Yorkers on whether to stay, speak out, or step away.
SOURCES: THE GATEWAY PUNDIT – Jewish Organizations Urge Mass Evacuation from NYC After Radical Muslim Socialist Zohran Mamdani Wins Democrat Mayoral Primary
THE JERUSALEM POST – Israel critic Mamdani shocks Cuomo in NYC Democratic mayoral primary focused on Jewish issues
FRANCE 24 – Upstart socialist stuns political veteran in NYC mayoral primary
